Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 vs. Nitto Trail Grappler

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

For many years, Nitto Trail Grappler tires have been the preferred choice for off-road drivers.

The efficiency of these tires is undeniable, making them good for on-road driving as well.

Not many tires can compete with the Trail Grappler, but one that does is the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2.

It’s not regularly that people compare these two tires, but knowing their differences could help you make a better decision.

Here, we’ll review each one, and then we’ll understand better what sets them apart.

So, if you wonder which one to buy between Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 vs. Nitto Trail Grappler, you’ve come to the right place.

Let’s start by discussing the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2.

Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 and Nitto Trail Grappler Comparison

Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 Nitto Trail Grappler
PROS1. The aggressive tread pattern is effective under different circumstances

2. All-terrain traction & proper driving response

3. Good handling & maneuverability on-road

4. Does fairly well on light snow

5. Durable
1. Incredible balance for on & off-road driving

2. Tackles deep mud, mud, gravel, dirt & more

3. Quiet performance on the highway

4. Smooth even at high speeds

5. Good tread life
CONS1. On-road noise1. Relatively heavy

Comparing these two tires leads to an overwhelming win by the Nitto Trail Grappler.

That’s not to say the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 is bad, but it surely doesn’t put up a performance as good as Nitto’s tire does.

Efficiency at All Terrains

Efficiency at All Terrains

While both tires do fairly well on and off the road, the Nitto Trail Grappler offers many more benefits for drivers.

The resistance is much better, allowing you to get out of tricky situations while driving tough terrains.

On the highway, the Trail Grappler’s performance is smoother and ultra-quiet, much for the driver’s convenience.


Owning a Nitto Trail Grappler ensures a quiet performance on the road. The noise produced is almost non-existent, while the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 could be pretty loud sometimes. Not always, but sporadically.

Look & Weight

We could argue that the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 does better in two areas: its look and its weight. When compared to the Trail Grappler, this tire is lighter and better-looking.

Unfortunately, those two features don’t matter that much since they don’t have any effect on the tire’s performance.

Pro Comp Xtreme MT2

With a fitting design ideal for SUV, 4×4, and light truck vehicles, the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 tire comes the perfect choice for on and off-road driving. Regardless of how tough the surface may be, the tire manages to deliver excellent results for the driver’s comfort.

The tire’s build features a Tri-Ply build, which offers high puncture resistance for the sidewall.

Additionally, there are two steel belts and the spiral-wound nylon overwrap, which are to improve the tire’s strength to handle rugged terrains and heavy loads.

Besides doing well on tricky trails or highways, drivers will also be able to tackle environmental conditions.

The silica tread compound included, and the computer-optimized tread pattern, guarantee proper stability on either wet or dry conditions.

Another huge improvement is the road noise. Sure enough, you’ll still be able to hear the tire on-road sporadically, but its design reduces it significantly.

When compared to other MT tires, you won’t experience as much noise as you did before.

And the success of the tire is possible due to the aggressive tread design and its durability.

While there’s some noise, it’s a regular issue that you’d experience with most mud tires anyway.

If we consider the solid build and its performance on and off-road, a few noises shouldn’t be a concern.

Latest Comparison: Extreme Country vs Fun Country Tires

Nitto Trail Grappler

There may be plenty of newer tires out there, but some drivers would still prefer the Nitto Trail Grapplers, and it’s no surprise.

The 3D tapered groove tread design of those tires is convenient for many reasons; one of those reasons being the extra biting edges for off-road driving.

And the tire does remarkably well for off-road driving. The deep center sipe guarantees good traction, even over wet surfaces.

Drivers will have complete control over the tires, and thus, over their driving, guaranteeing fun and safe ride.

Off-road driving comes with many risks. Luckily, the tire has protection to prevent damage.

For instance, the reinforced shoulder groove avoids compromising the block stiffness. Also, it includes ejectors to keep stones away for tread protection.

Even though the tire can be a bit expensive, its efficiency makes it a worthy acquisition.

Other than doing great off-road, the performance on-road is also satisfying.
You can hit the pedal to go at high speeds, and the tire will still feel smooth and quiet.

Since it’s a tire designed for off-road driving, its performance on-road is quite impressive.

The resistant sidewall and 3-ply build will allow you to achieve many feats while you’re out there driving.

It may be hard to believe, but the only negative you’d heard about this tire is the weight, and it isn’t even that bad.

Every other feature makes the Nitto Trail Grappler a wise investment.

Related Guide: Rock Crawling Tires Review

Frequently Asked Questions

Here we have the most commonly asked queries regarding the two products:

Is the Nitto Trail Grappler good?

Yes, and for many reasons. The dual sidewall design, the tread block arrangement, the shoulder groove, and many more features make it an ideal choice worth the money.

It’s a reliable tire that won’t let you down regardless of the circumstances, be it terrestrial or climatic.

Why go for the Xtreme MT2 tire?

This tire is particularly good for full-size trucks, and SUVs, among other vehicles.

It’s a strong tire that puts up a lot of weight, and it’ll do well on and off the road, depending on your needs. Even though it’s far from being the best, it manages to meet the expectations of many drivers.

What’s the more expensive tire?

The Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 is often the most expensive choice out of the two.

Fairly enough, both tires can be quite expensive, so make sure to estimate a budget of how much you’re willing to invest.

Is the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 any better than the Trail Grappler?

Some drivers would agree that the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 is better looking and lighter than the Trail Grappler.

In fact, many decide not to go for the Trail Grappler because it can be unpleasantly heavy. It’s easily the biggest issue with this series of Nitto tires.

Which one to buy?

Experienced drivers would advise you to go for the Trail Grappler. It’s as reliable as it’s efficient, delivering outstanding results on any surface.

Also, you won’t have to worry about wet or dry surfaces either, as the tire pulls through safely.


If there’s anything our Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 vs. Nitto Trail Grappler article has taught us, is that the latter continues to be the wisest choice out of the two.

With higher resistance, a quieter ride, and good performance on and off the road, the Trail Grappler is a tire you don’t want to miss.

The Pro Comp Xtreme MT2 is still a good tire, but it isn’t the best when compared to the Trail Grappler.

Drivers may not be fond of its price either, which could be pretty high for some budgets.

Related Guide:

Michelin Defender VS Michelin X Tour